Pita Bowl

Extra virgin vs light olive oil

Extra virgin olive oil is unrefined oil pressed from olives with no heat or chemicals, so it keeps a fruity, peppery flavor and more natural antioxidants, while light olive oil is mostly refined olive oil that is light in flavor and color, not in calories. Use extra virgin when you want flavor; use light when you want a neutral, heat-tolerant oil.

What light actually means

The word light on an olive oil bottle is a marketing term, and it confuses a lot of people. It refers to taste and color, not fat or calories. All olive oils, like all oils, have roughly 120 calories per tablespoon.

Light or extra light olive oil is typically refined olive oil, sometimes blended with a little virgin olive oil. Refining uses filtering, heat and other processing to strip out flavor, color and defects. The result is pale, neutral and more uniform.

What makes oil extra virgin

Extra virgin is the top grade. The oil must be extracted mechanically, without chemical solvents or high heat, and meet chemical limits, including low free acidity, as well as pass a taste panel with no defects and some positive fruitiness. The International Olive Council sets these standards, and the USDA has similar grades in the United States, though enforcement is uneven.

Because it is unrefined, extra virgin oil keeps polyphenols and other compounds that give it its bitterness and pepperiness. That sting at the back of your throat from a good oil is a sign of those compounds.

Between extra virgin and light sit other grades. Virgin olive oil is also unrefined but has minor flavor defects or slightly higher acidity. Pure olive oil, sometimes just labeled olive oil, is a blend of refined oil with some virgin oil for a bit of flavor. Pomace oil is extracted from the leftover olive paste with solvents and is the lowest grade.

Cooking with each

Light olive oil has a higher smoke point, commonly cited around 465 to 470°F, and no strong taste. That makes it handy for baking, high-heat searing and frying, or anything where you do not want olive flavor.

Extra virgin olive oil is best where you can taste it: salad dressings, a finishing drizzle on hummus or soup, dipping bread, and everyday sautéing. Despite its lower smoke point, often listed around 350 to 410°F, studies suggest it holds up well during normal home cooking because its antioxidants slow breakdown.

If you only buy one, most cooks recommend a decent everyday extra virgin. Store it in a dark bottle away from the stove and use it within a few months of opening.

Price is a reasonable but imperfect signal. Very cheap extra virgin oil is often old or blended, while expensive oil can still be stale if it has sat on a bright shelf. Smaller bottles you finish quickly usually taste better than a large tin that lingers.

Spotting a good bottle

Look for a harvest date, not just a best-by date, and a dark glass or tin container. A specific origin is a good sign. Taste is the real test: fresh extra virgin oil should smell green or fruity, not musty or like crayons.

Pita Bowl in Mission Beach cooks with olive oil and avocado oil rather than seed oils. If you are curious about which olive oil grade goes into a particular dish, ask at the counter.

Quick answers

Does light olive oil have fewer calories?
No. Light refers to flavor and color. It has the same calories as extra virgin and every other olive oil.
Can I fry with extra virgin olive oil?
Yes, for most home frying and sautéing. It is more expensive for deep-frying, and the flavor is partly lost at high heat, which is why some cooks use a refined oil for that.
Is light olive oil still healthy?
It is still mostly monounsaturated fat, similar to extra virgin. It has fewer polyphenols because of refining, so extra virgin is generally considered the better choice for everyday use.

Try it at Pita Bowl

Related guides

More guides

Pita Bowl is at 3833 Mission Blvd in Mission Beach. Everything is made fresh daily with no seed oils.

Order Online
Order Online