Where each oil comes from
Both are pressed from the flesh of a fruit rather than extracted from seeds, which is part of why they are often grouped together. Olive oil has been made around the Mediterranean for thousands of years. Avocado oil is much newer as a widely sold cooking oil, with commercial production taking off in recent decades in places such as Mexico, New Zealand, Kenya and California.
Each comes in less-refined and refined forms. Extra virgin olive oil and unrefined avocado oil keep more flavor and color. Refined versions are filtered and processed to be lighter and more heat-tolerant.
Unlike many seed oils, neither is typically extracted with chemical solvents in its premium forms. Some lower-grade oils, such as olive pomace oil, are solvent-extracted, which is one reason labels matter.
Flavor and smoke point
Extra virgin olive oil tastes fruity, grassy or peppery, sometimes with a pleasant bitterness. That flavor is a feature in dressings, dips and drizzles, and it carries into cooked food.
Refined avocado oil is very mild, close to neutral, with a buttery smoothness. Unrefined avocado oil is greener and tastes faintly of avocado.
Smoke points vary widely by grade and source, so treat numbers as rough guides. Refined avocado oil is commonly cited at around 480 to 520°F. Extra virgin olive oil is often listed somewhere between 350 and 410°F, and refined olive oil higher. Research also suggests extra virgin olive oil is more stable under normal cooking heat than its smoke point implies, thanks to its antioxidants.
How they compare nutritionally
The fat profiles are similar. Both are mostly oleic acid, a monounsaturated fat, with modest amounts of saturated and polyunsaturated fat. Calories are essentially the same, as with all oils.
The research base is different. Extra virgin olive oil is a core part of the Mediterranean diet and has been studied extensively, including in large trials such as PREDIMED. Avocado oil has far less human research. Neither should be treated as a cure-all.
On the wider seed oil debate, mainstream groups such as the American Heart Association do not consider seed oils harmful in normal diets, and the discussion is ongoing. Choosing olive or avocado oil is a reasonable preference either way.
Quality is a real issue for both. Studies, including research from the University of California, Davis, have found that many avocado oils on store shelves were stale or mixed with other oils. Buy from brands you trust and store oil away from heat and light.
Why Pita Bowl uses both
Pita Bowl cooks with olive oil and avocado oil instead of seed oils such as canola or soybean. Using the two together is a common approach: olive oil brings Mediterranean flavor, and avocado oil handles high-heat cooking without adding a strong taste.
That applies to the shawarma, chicken tikka and falafel alike, so whatever you order, the cooking fat is one of these two.