How to tell them apart
Black lentils are tiny and dark, and they look a bit like caviar when cooked, which is where the beluga nickname comes from. Their skins are relatively thick, so they keep their round shape and a slight pop.
Brown lentils are the most common lentil in American supermarkets. They are larger, flat and khaki to light brown, with thinner skins. Green lentils are close relatives, and the two are often sold interchangeably. French green lentils, called du Puy when grown in that region, behave more like black lentils.
Red and yellow lentils are a different category again. They are usually split and hulled, cook in 15 minutes or so, and collapse into a purée, which makes them ideal for dal and soups but not for salads.
Flavor, texture and cook time
Black lentils taste earthy and slightly richer, with a firm bite even when fully cooked. They usually take about 20 to 30 minutes of simmering and do not need soaking.
Brown lentils are milder and more neutral. They cook in a similar 20 to 30 minutes, but they go from tender to mushy quickly if you are not watching. That softness is useful in soups, where they thicken the broth, and in Levantine mujadara, where they cook with rice or bulgur under fried onions.
A practical tip for both: simmer gently rather than boiling hard, and salt toward the end if you want skins that stay intact.
Black lentils are also good for making ahead. They keep their texture in the fridge for several days, so a batch can go into salads, grain bowls and wraps all week. Brown lentils keep well too but are better suited to dishes where softness does not matter.
Price and availability differ a little. Brown lentils are the cheapest and easiest to find in most stores. Black lentils are usually sold in smaller bags, often near specialty grains, and cost somewhat more.
Nutrition
All lentils are nutritious, and the differences between colors are small. They are rich in plant protein and fiber, and they supply iron, folate and potassium. Black lentils contain anthocyanins, the same type of pigments found in blueberries, which give them their color.
For most people, the best lentil is the one that suits the dish, since the nutritional gap is modest. Pairing lentils with a vitamin C source such as lemon or tomatoes may help the body absorb their iron.
Black lentils in the Earth Bowl
Pita Bowl uses black lentils as the base of the Earth Bowl instead of rice. Their firm texture keeps the bowl from turning soft and lets the other components stand out: mixed greens, falafel, hummus, roasted eggplant dip, pickled onions, cucumbers, feta and jalapeño cilantro dressing.
Between the lentils, falafel and hummus, the bowl carries plenty of plant protein, and it is listed as vegetarian and gluten-friendly. It includes feta, so ask to leave it off if you are vegan.