Read the label
Look for a harvest date, not just a best-by date. Olive oil is best within about a year or so of harvest, and a best-by date can be set long after that. A recent harvest date is one of the clearest quality signals.
Check where the olives came from. A specific country, region or estate is a better sign than vague wording like packed in or a blend of oils from several countries. Third-party certification seals from olive oil associations or testing programs show the oil has been checked against a standard.
Extra virgin is the grade to buy for flavor. Plain olive oil, light olive oil and pomace oil are refined and much milder.
Look at the packaging
Price is an imperfect guide, but extremely cheap extra virgin olive oil should make you cautious. Good oil costs money to grow, harvest quickly and mill well. A mid-priced bottle with a harvest date and a clear origin is often better value than a cheap one with neither.
Light and heat damage olive oil. Dark glass, tins and opaque containers protect it better than clear bottles. Avoid bottles that have been sitting in a sunny window or under bright store lights for months.
Buy a size you'll use within a couple of months of opening. A large bottle is only a bargain if you finish it while it's fresh.
Color is not a quality indicator. Good oil can be green, gold or somewhere in between, depending on the olives and when they were picked. Professional tasters use colored glasses specifically so color doesn't influence their judgment.
Taste it
Oils from different olive varieties and regions taste noticeably different. Some are mild and buttery, others very green and peppery. Trying a few side by side is the quickest way to learn what you like.
Pour a little into a small glass, warm it in your hand, smell it and then sip. Fresh extra virgin olive oil has three positive traits that tasters look for: fruitiness, which can be grassy, green or ripe; bitterness on the tongue; and pungency, a peppery tickle in the throat that may make you cough. That cough is a sign of fresh oil, often linked to natural compounds such as oleocanthal.
Defects are easy to learn. Rancid oil smells like crayons, putty or stale nuts. Musty or vinegary smells point to poor handling of the olives. Oil that tastes of almost nothing is probably old or refined.
Store it well
Keep olive oil sealed, in a cool, dark cupboard away from the stove. Don't refrigerate it for everyday use; it can turn cloudy and solid, though that does no harm and it clears at room temperature.
Once you know what fresh olive oil tastes like, you'll notice it everywhere it's used well, from dressings and dips to grilled food. Pita Bowl in Mission Beach cooks with olive oil and avocado oil, and no seed oils.