A California cheese
Monterey Jack takes its name from the Monterey area on California's Central Coast, where it was made and sold in the 19th century; the "Jack" is usually credited to businessman David Jacks, who marketed it widely. The cheese itself grew out of the soft white cheeses made at California's Spanish missions.
Pepper jack is a younger, American variation. Chiles are folded into the curds before pressing, giving the finished cheese its signature colored flecks.
Taste and melting
Young Monterey Jack is mild, buttery and high in moisture, so it melts into a smooth, stretchy layer without turning greasy. The peppers add a warm, slow heat that's usually modest; most of the flavor is creamy dairy with a little bite.
That makes it a favorite for quesadillas, burgers, nachos and grilled sandwiches, and anywhere you want melt plus a bit of spice.
In a shawarma wrap
Pepper jack isn't Middle Eastern at all, which is the point of Pita Bowl's Cali Shawarma Wrap. It brings California burrito habits to shawarma: pepper jack, steak shawarma, fries, guacamole and garlic aioli rolled up together. The cheese melts into the warm meat and fries, and its mild chile heat meets the garlic aioli and avocado.
If you like the idea but want something closer to tradition, try a wrap with feta, tahini or one of the house dips instead.
At home, pepper jack keeps for several weeks wrapped in wax or parchment paper and then loosely in plastic in the fridge. Shred it cold, let it come up to room temperature before serving on a cheese board, and remember that, like most cheeses, it contains milk.
If you can't find pepper jack, plain Monterey Jack with a few slices of pickled jalapeño gets close. Mozzarella or a young cheddar will melt similarly but lacks the peppers' warmth.
For grilled sandwiches and wraps, shred pepper jack rather than slicing it, so it melts quickly and evenly before the bread overbrowns. Pre-shredded bags are convenient but contain anti-caking starch, which can keep the cheese from melting as smoothly.