Four ingredients, a lot of technique
Toum means garlic in Arabic. The sauce starts with peeled garlic cloves crushed with salt, traditionally in a mortar and now usually in a food processor. Oil is then added in a slow, thin stream, alternating with lemon juice or ice water, until the mixture turns pale, thick and almost like whipped cream.
The garlic itself is the emulsifier. Its compounds hold the oil and water together, which is why toum works without eggs. Adding the oil too fast breaks the emulsion and you end up with a greasy, runny sauce. Many cooks keep a little ice water nearby to rescue it.
Removing the green sprout from the center of older garlic cloves can reduce bitterness. A common ratio is roughly one part garlic to four parts oil by volume, with lemon juice and water added a spoonful at a time between additions of oil. Expect several minutes of patient blending; rushing is the main reason toum fails.
The oil question
Traditional and restaurant toum is usually made with a neutral oil, which in practice often means canola, sunflower or other seed oils. Neutral oils keep the flavor clean and help the sauce stay fluffy.
Extra virgin olive oil is trickier. Blended at high speed, it can turn bitter and makes a heavier sauce, so cooks who use it often mix it with a milder oil or whisk part of it in by hand. Avocado oil and light-flavored olive oils are good alternatives if you'd rather avoid seed oils.
How to use it
Toum is potent, so a little goes a long way. It's standard with chicken shawarma wraps and shish tawook, alongside grilled or rotisserie chicken, and as a dip for fries or bread. It's also stirred into marinades, spread on sandwiches and thinned with lemon as a salad dressing.
Homemade toum keeps in the fridge for a few weeks in a sealed jar, and its sharp raw-garlic bite mellows a bit over the first few days. Because it contains raw garlic in oil, keep it refrigerated and use a clean spoon.
Its bite fades when cooked, so toum brushed on bread or chicken before grilling tastes milder and sweeter than it does raw.
Toum vs aioli, and at Pita Bowl
Toum and modern aioli look similar but aren't the same. Most aioli today is garlic mayonnaise, made with egg yolk. Toum has no egg, more garlic and a lighter, fluffier texture.
Lebanese restaurants often serve it in small bowls on the side so diners can add as much as they like.
Pita Bowl's menu lists a garlic sauce on the Zesty Chicken Wrap, Chicken and Steak Shawarma Fries and Pita Nachos, and a separate garlic aioli on the Cali Shawarma Wrap. Pita Bowl says its sauces are made without seed oils. If you want to know exactly how the garlic sauce is made or whether it contains egg, ask when you order.