Red, and named for it
Muhammara comes from an Arabic word meaning reddened, which describes it well. The color comes from roasted red bell peppers and Aleppo pepper, a dried chili with moderate heat and a fruity, slightly oily character.
Aleppo, in northern Syria, has a deep tradition of red-pepper cooking, and muhammara is one of its signature mezze. It's also popular in Lebanon, Turkey (where it's sometimes called acuka or muhammara) and across the Syrian diaspora.
Aleppo pepper has become easier to find in US grocery stores and spice shops. Because of the war in Syria, much of what's sold under the name now comes from neighboring Turkey, where a similar pepper called pul biber is grown. Either works in muhammara. If you can't find it, a mix of sweet paprika and a pinch of red pepper flakes is a common stand-in.
What goes into it
The base is roasted red peppers, charred and peeled, or in some recipes a red pepper paste. Toasted walnuts give body and richness. Breadcrumbs, or toasted bread blitzed into crumbs, thicken the mixture so it holds its shape.
Pomegranate molasses is the ingredient that makes muhammara taste like itself. It's a thick, dark syrup of reduced pomegranate juice with a sharp sweet-sour flavor. Olive oil, cumin, garlic, lemon and salt round it out.
Texture varies. Some cooks pound everything by hand for a coarse, nubbly dip. Others blend it smooth. Both are traditional.
Some cooks add a little red pepper paste for deeper color, and a few skip the breadcrumbs in favor of more walnuts.
How it tastes and how it's served
Expect sweetness from the peppers and molasses, earthiness from walnuts and cumin, a little smoke, and a slow, mild heat from the Aleppo pepper. It's richer than hummus and more assertive than baba ganoush.
On a mezze table, muhammara is usually spread in a shallow dish, topped with olive oil and whole walnut halves, and eaten with warm bread. It's also excellent alongside grilled chicken or lamb, spread in sandwiches, spooned over roasted vegetables, or thinned with a little water and lemon as a sauce for fish.
Muhammara often tastes better the next day, once the flavors settle. It keeps for several days in the fridge with a thin layer of olive oil on top. Let it come to room temperature before serving, because cold dulls the pepper and molasses.
Allergy and diet notes
Muhammara contains tree nuts (walnuts) and, in most versions, wheat breadcrumbs. Anyone avoiding nuts or gluten should skip it or ask carefully. It's usually vegan, since it's built from vegetables, nuts, bread, oil and molasses.
Muhammara isn't on Pita Bowl's menu. Pita Bowl's three dips are hummus, tzatziki and roasted eggplant dip, and if you're avoiding nuts, note that the baklava contains them and ask the staff about other desserts and shared prep. If you enjoy muhammara's sweet-smoky side, the roasted eggplant dip is the closest in spirit on the menu.