How baklava is made
Baklava starts with phyllo, a paper-thin dough made from flour, water and a little oil or vinegar. Sheets are stacked one at a time, each brushed with melted butter, with a layer of chopped nuts in the middle or spread between several layers.
Before baking, the pastry is cut into diamonds or squares so the syrup can soak in later. It bakes until golden and crisp, and then a syrup is poured over it, either a sugar syrup often flavored with lemon, rose water or orange blossom water, or honey. The contrast between the hot pastry and the syrup, or the reverse, is what lets it absorb without going soggy.
Good baklava is crisp on top, moist in the middle, and sweet without being sticky all the way through.
Where baklava comes from
The baklava most people know today took shape in the kitchens of the Ottoman Empire, where it was a prized dessert in Istanbul's palace kitchens. From there it spread across the empire, which is why Turkey, Greece, Lebanon, Syria, the Balkans and other places all have their own versions.
Earlier roots are debated. Food historians point to layered bread and nut desserts from Central Asia, Persia and the Byzantine world as possible ancestors, but there's no single agreed origin. Several countries claim it, and each one's version is a little different.
Pistachio baklava
Pistachio baklava is often associated with Gaziantep in southeastern Turkey, a region known for growing pistachios. It's usually made with bright green pistachios and tends to be more delicate, with a buttery, slightly sweet nut flavor.
Pistachios cost more than walnuts, so pistachio baklava is often treated as the premium version. It's the one many people picture when they think of Turkish baklava.
Walnut baklava
Walnut baklava is common in Greek, Balkan and many home recipes. Walnuts have a deeper, earthier flavor with a slight bitterness from their skins, which balances the sweet syrup well. Greek versions often add cinnamon or cloves.
If you find baklava too sweet in general, walnut is often the better place to start because the nut flavor pushes back against the sugar.
Which to try, and how to eat it
Choose pistachio if you want something rich, buttery and a bit more refined. Choose walnut if you like a stronger nut flavor and a little less sweetness. Many people end up ordering one of each.
Pita Bowl makes both in-house. The menu lists phyllo, nuts, honey and butter as the ingredients, so they're sweetened with honey and contain dairy and tree nuts. Both are vegetarian.
Baklava keeps well at room temperature, covered, for several days. Refrigerating it can make the phyllo lose its crispness.
Baklava is rich, so pieces are usually small, a few bites each. In Turkey and the Levant it's traditionally served with strong coffee or black tea, which balances the sweetness. Some places serve it with a scoop of ice cream or clotted cream. Eat it with your fingers or a small fork, and expect it to be a little sticky.
If you're trying baklava for the first time, start with one piece of each nut so you can compare them side by side. Look for a golden, crisp top and nuts that taste fresh rather than dusty. Baklava that is soggy all the way through usually had too much syrup or sat too long.