Same seasonings, different base
The two dips often share the same supporting cast: tahini, lemon juice, garlic, salt and a pool of olive oil on top. What really separates them is the main ingredient. Hummus is built on cooked chickpeas. Baba ganoush is built on eggplant that's been roasted or charred over an open flame until the skin blackens and the flesh collapses.
That charring is the defining step. It gives baba ganoush a smoky taste that hummus doesn't have. Eggplant cooked gently in an oven without much char tastes milder and sweeter.
Each dip has its own preparation challenge. Hummus depends on very soft chickpeas and patient blending to turn smooth. Baba ganoush depends on draining the eggplant well after roasting, since eggplant holds a lot of bitter, watery liquid that can make the dip thin and sharp. Many cooks let the scooped flesh sit in a strainer for several minutes before mixing. Hummus can be blended fully smooth in a food processor, while baba ganoush is often mashed with a fork for a slightly rough texture.
A note on names
Names for eggplant dips vary by country, and the same word can mean different things. In much of the US and in many Levantine kitchens, baba ganoush means eggplant with tahini. In parts of Lebanon and Syria, the tahini version is often called mutabal, while baba ganoush can refer to a chunkier eggplant salad with tomato, onion, peppers and pomegranate molasses, without tahini.
Because of this, a menu labeled eggplant dip could be any of several recipes. If you're avoiding sesame or dairy, ask what's in it.
Texture, taste and nutrition
Hummus is thick, smooth and dense, with a mild, nutty flavor. Baba ganoush is looser and silkier, sometimes slightly stringy, with smoke, tang and a bit of bitterness from the charred skin.
Hummus is the more filling of the two. Chickpeas bring plant protein, fiber and carbohydrates, so a serving of hummus goes further in a meal. Baba ganoush is mostly vegetable, so it's usually lighter, though the tahini and olive oil still add healthy fats.
Both are typically vegan and gluten-free by ingredients, and both often contain sesame. Neither needs dairy, though some eggplant dips are finished with yogurt.
When to choose each
Choose hummus when the dip is doing a lot of work in the meal, such as in a falafel wrap or as the main protein boost in a vegetarian bowl. Choose baba ganoush when you want strong flavor in a small amount, or something to stand up to steak or lamb.
You don't have to pick. Pita Bowl puts both side by side in the Earth Bowl and the Steak Shawarma Bowl, which pair hummus with eggplant dip. Pita Bowl lists its version simply as roasted eggplant dip, so ask if you need to know whether it contains tahini. You can also order either one with warm pita in Dip and Pita.